First stint Anderson was hired as the 15th head football coach at the
University of Iowa before the 1939 season.
Iowa had a record of just 2–13–1 in 1937 and 1938 under
Irl Tubbs, and the Hawkeyes had finished among the worst three teams in the
Big Ten Conference standings every year in the 1930s except 1933. Iowa had won just one conference game in the last three years, and the team they beat,
Chicago, announced that they would be dropping their football program following the 1939 season. Anderson sought to change Iowa's fortunes immediately. He put the 85 football players who showed up for spring practice through an intense workout. Only 37 players would earn football letters in 1939 for Iowa. Anderson felt the 1939 team could be a good one if the starters played significant minutes. Before the first game,
The Des Moines Register had a small note stating that "a set of iron men may be developed to play football for Iowa." The
1939 Hawkeyes, nicknamed the "Ironmen", would become one of the greatest teams in school history and certainly the most romanticized. Led by
Nile Kinnick, the 1939
Heisman Trophy winner, the Hawkeyes put together a 6–1–1 record, the best overall record in the Big Ten, though
Ohio State edged out Iowa for the conference title. Many of Anderson's players played complete games during that season for the Hawkeyes. Anderson was named national coach of the year by several organizations. Jim Gallager of the
Chicago Herald-American wrote, "It's doubtful if any coach in football history ever accomplished such an amazing renaissance as Eddie Anderson has worked at Iowa." Anderson was given a
Cadillac by Iowa fans and a bonus by the university after his performance during the 1939 season. He was also given a significant share of stock in
Amana Refrigeration by the founder and CEO of the company, George Foersner, as a reward for his coaching that season. When Anderson retired from football in the late 1960s, he cashed in his stock for over a million dollars. After two more average seasons, Iowa started the 1942 season with a 6–2 record and was in contention for the Big Ten title, but consecutive road conference losses at
Minnesota and
Michigan to end the season doomed Iowa's chances. After that season, Anderson took a leave of absence to serve in the
U.S. Army Medical Corps during World War II. Iowa left the football program in the hands of interim coaches
Slip Madigan and
Clem Crowe while Anderson was gone from 1943 to 1945. Anderson was a gifted doctor who performed at the
University of Iowa Hospital in the morning before coaching in the afternoon. He had been studying
urology under the Head of Urology at the hospital. When Anderson returned in 1946, he was told that if he retired from coaching, he would be named the successor to Dr. Alcock. Anderson turned down the request and continued practicing medicine on a part-time basis.
Second stint By the time Anderson had returned from the service, Iowa football was again in the cellar of the Big Ten. Before the 1946 season, Anderson was hospitalized for 19 days with a parasite infection. He returned to lead Iowa to four wins in their first five games, which was as many wins as Iowa had during his three-year absence. Still, Iowa slumped to a 5–4 final record, leading two former players to write a scathing editorial about Anderson. The editorial asked, "How long will Dr. Anderson ride on the laurels that
Nile Kinnick won for him?" In 1947, a 2–2–1 start was followed by three straight losses. One day before Iowa's final game at
Minnesota, Anderson submitted his resignation at Iowa, citing "considerable loose talk" among Iowa fans as one reason. The Hawkeye football team responded with a powerful effort against Minnesota, defeating the Gophers, 13–7. Fans begged Anderson to reconsider, and the Iowa athletic board denied his resignation, promising him a larger coaching staff and other football improvement s. Anderson decided to stay, saying, "I'm glad we got things straightened out." Anderson used his larger coaching staff to hire
Leonard Raffensperger as the head of the freshman team. After two more average seasons in 1948 and 1949, Anderson was approached again by Holy Cross, which now had a coaching vacancy. Ohio State made a rare concession and offered their football coach faculty tenure, so Anderson made the same request to Iowa athletic director
Paul Brechler. Brechler could not promise Anderson anything, so Anderson resigned and took the head coaching position at Holy Cross. He had a 35–33–2 record in eight years at Iowa. ==Later life, death, and honors==