Edgar, Puccini's second opera, was composed on a commission from the publisher
Ricordi after the successful reception of his first stage work,
Le Villi. The plot indicates the influence of Wagner's
Tannhäuser. Both centre on medieval knights struggling between a life of sensual indulgence and ideal love. Edgar is "torn between the sacred love of Fidelia and the profane love of Tigrana"; Wagner's hero indulges himself with Venus while pining for the love of Elizabeth. The gypsy-like figure of Tigrana (supposedly the child of "wandering Moors") also parallels the anti-heroine of
Bizet's
Carmen. The original version had four acts and was tepidly received. In January 1890, Ricordi published a revised version, including a different ending for act 2. In the autumn of 1891, Puccini revised the work again, cutting the last act and producing a
three-act version which would again be revised in 1905. In this final form the opera had even less success than in its original four-act structure. Some of the music that was cut in 1891 was reused in
Tosca and became the beautiful act 3 duet, "Amaro sol per te m'era il morire!". The funeral march from act 3 was played at Puccini's funeral, conducted by
Arturo Toscanini and the aria "Addio, mio dolce amor" ("Farewell, My Sweet Love") from the same act was sung. Puccini finally gave up on
Edgar and in later years, bitterly repudiated the work. He wrote On a copy of the score that he sent to a friend, the English woman Sybil Seligman, he wrote scathing remarks against parts of the score and amended the title to read:
E Dio ti
Gu
ARdi da quest'opera! (And may God protect you from this opera!) The autograph of Acts 1 and 3 of the original version is preserved in the
Archivio Ricordi in Milan. ==Performance history==