Abolitionism and temperance For a period of time he was a trustee of Milwaukee when it was a village. In 1843, he was elected Milwaukee's first sheriff, running as an independent. At this early stage of his political career, Holton was already well known as an
abolitionist and
temperance advocate. While ordinarily these were political liabilities, he defeated future Wisconsin governor and Democrat
William A. Barstow due to the fact that the Democrats were divided by an internal party squabble. In 1845, Holton was the
Liberty Party candidate for territorial representative to Congress, losing to
Morgan Lewis Martin, who drew 6,803 votes to 5,787 for
Whig James Collins and 790 for Holton. In 1850 Holton was at the center of a fight over a law assigning to establishments selling liquor liability for harm caused by people who were intoxicated. The law was introduced by state senator
John B. Smith and was known as the Smith liquor law. When demonstrations against the law turned into minor riots, a committee was organized to defend the law; Holton was named Chair of the committee. The outcome of the controversy had the unintended consequence that it strengthened the political position of the Democratic Party and weakened the
Free-soilers allied with Holton.
Gubernatorial Candidacy Holton was the nominee of the
Free Soil Party for
Governor of Wisconsin in the
1853 election. He was defeated by Democrat William A. Barstow, but finished far ahead of
Whig Party candidate
Henry S. Baird.
Republican Party Holton was one of two principal candidates at the 1857
Wisconsin Republican Party convention, when the party was still very young. The other major candidate was
Walter D. McIndoe, a lumber industrialist from
Wausau. Holton's abolitionist passions and his connections with the Milwaukee elite gave him strong support, but McIndoe's more rough-hewn personality resonated better with the frontier character of the state at the time. As such, they split the vote, neither able to garner a majority for the nomination. When it became apparent that the convention was at an impasse, and the delegates were released from their obligation, the votes eventually were cast in favor of the third candidate,
Alexander Randall, who became the obvious compromise candidate. Randall was the first in a long line of Republican governors in Wisconsin. Holton served in the Wisconsin Assembly in 1860, representing the Fourth Ward of Milwaukee. In 1862,
President Lincoln appointed him
allotment commissioner, overseeing a policy where 1/3 of each
Union soldier's pay was sent directly to family back home for safekeeping, intended to prevent wasteful spending in camp. He eventually had to resign the commission due to poor health. ==Semi-retirement==