Gurney competed in the Republican Party with Bill Cramer, a senior leader in Florida who in 1954 had been the first of his party elected to Congress from the state in the 20th century. They were prospective primary opponents for a vacant Senate seat in 1968 until Cramer yielded to Gurney. He believed that Gurney would support him for the other Senate seat, which
Spessard Holland was expected to vacate in 1970. Cramer's former law partner
Herman Goldner had been
mayor of
St. Petersburg for one term and was a
Moderate Republican. He ran in the primary against Gurney in 1968 but, underfunded and distrusted by many conservative Republican voters, Goldner received few votes. Gurney handily won the Senate seat, carrying all but four counties in the race against Democrat
LeRoy Collins, a former governor. Gurney and Cramer traveled in the state in various party-building ventures. In the fall of 1969, Cramer declared his candidacy for the Senate, urged by President Richard M. Nixon to do so.
Spessard Holland soon announced his expected retirement. Cramer expected Gurney's support. But in 1970, Gurney and Governor
Claude R. Kirk, Jr. opposed Cramer's nomination; they supported an intraparty rival,
George Harrold Carswell. He had been nominated that year to the Supreme Court and was rejected by the Senate, with critical comments about his "mediocrity and past "racism." Carswell stepped down from his seat on the
United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit in New Orleans in order to run for the Senate race. Cramer easily defeated Carswell in the primary for the Republican nomination, but relations within the party became bitter. Gurney did not agree that he and Cramer had a "gentlemen's agreement" about the Senate seat. That fall, Cramer lost to the Democratic senatorial nominee,
State Senator Lawton Chiles of
Lakeland. The Democrats also took the governorship in Florida, and that year they were generally victorious over Republican candidates in a sweep across the South. After the election, in his remaining months in office Governor Kirk selected Gurney's
Orlando law firm as the counsel for the
Florida Turnpike Authority, at a $100,000 annual retainer. Cramer's law firm received no state business. ==Indictments==