Truelove encountered legal trouble with both political and
birth control publications.
Tyrannicide pamphlet In 1858 he was prosecuted in the wake of the
Orsini affair, for publishing
Tyrannicide: Is it justifiable? by
William Edwin Adams. The prosecution was on grounds of
seditious libel; a charge of
blasphemy was dropped. After six months Truelove was cautioned by the judge,
Lord Chief Justice Campbell, and the matter was closed.
Obscenity charge In 1878 Truelove was tried for publishing an edition of
Robert Dale Owen's work
Moral Physiology, and spent four months in
Coldbath Fields Prison. Prosecuted in 1877, at the instigation of the
Society for the Suppression of Vice, Truelove had his trial postponed to allow the higher-profile contraception case involving
Charles Bradlaugh and
Annie Besant, and the publication of
Charles Knowlton's
The Fruits of Philosophy, to come to court first. A first trial of Truelove in February 1878 led to the jury not being able to come to a verdict. He was convicted after a second trial. In legal terms, prosecutions brought during the 1870s, and prompted by the Society for the Suppression of Vice, turned on the application of the
Obscene Publications Act 1857. A series of cases had been sought by Charles Hastings Collette, Secretary of the Society. It became a one-man campaign, ending in 1880 when the Society closed down. Truelove had displayed
Moral Physiology in his shop window, in High Holborn. Witnesses for Truelove's defence were
John Morrison Davidson and W. A. Hunger of the English Dialectical Society. The judge for the first trial was
Lord Chief Justice Cockburn; for the second,
Baron Pollock.
Publications on contraception The background in birth control was that Truelove had first published
George Drysdale's
The Elements of Social Science; or Physical, Sexual and Natural Religion, an influential pseudonymous text on contraception, in 1855, after Drysdale had had trouble finding a publisher; he also sold contraceptive devices. The book, cheaply produced, had reached a 14th edition by 1876; in all there were 35 editions, to 1905. Drysdale's authorship only came out in 1904, after his death. Owen's
Moral Physiology was an earlier birth control book from 1830, first published in the United States. Under the title
Individual, Family, and National Poverty, a pamphlet version of Drysdale's work was part of the case against Truelove. ==Family==