In July, 1865 Sheridan made his debut at
Niblo's Garden, New York in
Dion Boucicault's
Arrah Na Pouge, playing Beamish McGoul with Thomas Henry Glenney (his American debut) as Shawn the Post, Josephine Orton as Arrah Mellish and Mary Wells playing Katy. When
Edwin Forrest began his engagement at Niblo's that September, Sheridan would fill in as his substitute on the actor’s off days. Sheridan later returned as a lead actor to Pike's Opera House until the theatre was consumed by fire in March 1866. Over the following several seasons Sheridan was associated with theatres in St. Louis, Washington D. C., Boston, New Orleans and Philadelphia. In November 1867 he received praise for his interpretation of Captain Hawtree in the
T. W. Robertson play
Caste at the National Theatre, Washington D. C. By 1870 he was the lead actor at the
Chestnut Street Theatre, Philadelphia, and by the early 1870s Sheridan was a member of
Edwin Booth's company at
Booth's Theatre, New York performing
second lead in Shakespearean tragedies. Sheridan toured with stock companies headed by the comedian
John T. Raymond, actress
Julia Dean and British actors Mr. and Mrs. Rousby (
William Wybert Rousby and
Clara Marion Jesse Dowse). and had played the leading man opposite actresses
Lucille Western, Charlotte Thompson (1843-1898), Adele Belgarde (d. 1938, mother of film director
David Butler) and had appeared in England with McKee and Kitty Rankin playing The Parson in
Joaquin Miller's The Danites in the Sierras. Reportedly, Sheridan was most at ease when he starred in productions of
Casimir Delavigne's
Louis XI and
John Brougham's ''The Duke's Motto''. The role he was most identified with over his career was as Joseph Fioretti, a part he played numerous times in Leonard Grover's farce melodrama,
Our Boarding House. Sheridan was also remembered for his renditions of
Hamlet,
Richard III,
Cardinal Richelieu and other classical and contemporary roles played over a near thirty-year career. ==Personal life==