The All-Star Teams for the British Elite Ice Hockey League are voted for by members of Ice Hockey Journalists UK, and coaches and general managers of EIHL teams, to honour the best players at the end of each season.
2003–2004
First Team Second Team == 2004–2005 ==
2004–2005
First Team Second Team == 2005–2006 ==
2005–2006
First Team Second Team == 2006–2007 ==
2006–2007
First Team Second Team == 2007–2008 ==
2007–2008
First Team Second Team == 2008–2009 ==
2008–2009
First Team Second Team == 2009–2010 ==
2009–2010
First Team Second Team == 2010–2011 ==
2010–2011
First Team Second Team == 2011–2012 ==
2011–2012
First Team Second Team == 2012–2013 ==
2012–2013
First Team Second Team == 2013–2014 ==
2013–2014
First Team Second Team == 2014–2015 ==
2014–2015
First Team Second Team == 2015–2016 ==
2015–2016
First Team Second Team == 2016–2017 ==
2016–2017
First Team Second Team == 2017–2018 ==
2017–2018
First Team Second Team == 2018–2019 ==
2018–2019
First Team Second Team == 2019–2020 ==
2019–2020
First Team Second Team == 2021–2022 ==
2021–2022
First Team Second Team == 2022–2023 ==
2022–2023
First Team Second Team == 2023–2024 ==
2023–2024
First Team Second Team == 2024–2025 ==