In
El poeta, Moreno Torroba departed from his usual zarzuela style of composition. Unlike in zarzuelas, he wrote the opera as a
through-composed piece without the interruptions of dialogue or distinct arias, duets, and ensembles. It was also more
dissonant than typical of his style. American composer
George Gershwin, in particular, influenced Moreno Torroba in this opera. Spanish critic Antonio Fernández-Cid remarked on the noticeable influences of both Gershwin and
Puccini in the opera's score and praised the composer for his subtle "tone color, harmony, structure, and use of solos and
tuttis." Other critics found a similarity with the music of
Gian Carlo Menotti and
Leonard Bernstein. Some reviews commented especially on Moreno Torroba's old-fashioned style of composing. The critic for
Opera News claimed that the score exhibited an "arch-romanticism out of date for three or four generations." At the same time, she noted: "Vocal lines were full of melody and eminently singable, pacing was varied and orchestration thoroughly professional."
Speight Jenkins, writing in
Musical America, stressed similar points. He wrote: "Moreno Torroba's music suggested a time warp: the composer seemed to be creating as
Giordano might have and in no case were there harmonies which suggested the music of this century. The surprise was the honesty of the writing; most '
romantic' music composed in 1980 suggests a febrile Puccini, with the vivid color removed. On first hearing, Moreno Torroba's work sounded real and passionate, with the melodies effective though not quite overwhelming enough." ==Recordings==