Curt Smith's departure from Tears for Fears influenced Roland Orzabal's songwriting for the new album; Orzabal stated that "a lot of the songs were written while I was in a sense going through the 'divorce'... Things like "
Break It Down Again" refer to that to some degree, and "Fish Out of Water", obviously. I did psychotherapy for about six years. I stopped going regularly when I'd finished [the song] "Elemental", which I think probably says something. I think I'm moving on." The first single from
Elemental, "Break It Down Again", was a relatively successful release, making both the UK and US top 25 singles charts. When Smith (who rejoined Tears for Fears in 2000) was asked in 2022 what his favorite "Curt Smith-less Tears for Fears songs" are, Smith answered, "I have come to really like 'Break It Down Again'. We play that song nowadays and I enjoy playing it." "
Cold" was the second single from
Elemental to be released in the UK, but was not released in the US. According to Orzabal in the
Elemental EPK, the song was inspired by an encounter with a German photographer who was trying to take pictures of him while he was on-stage. The photographer tried to get Orzabal's attention but he was not in the mood for photos and kept turning his face away. He eventually received a note from the photographer asking 'how can someone who makes such warm music to be so cold'. The first 2 verses of the song describe this event. The song's lyrics, written by Orzabal, contain also references to prior associates of Tears for Fears such as the line
"Listened to my old friend Nockles, hoped that it would warm the cockles". "Nockles" is the nickname of former Tears for Fears keyboardist Nicky Holland, Orzabal's songwriting partner for much of the band's previous album,
The Seeds of Love. Orzabal also takes a swipe at former Tears for Fears business manager Paul King with the lyric ''"King got caught with his fingers in the till. Where's your calculator, will you leave it in your will?"'' after alleged discrepancies were discovered in King's prior management of the band's financial affairs. King declared bankruptcy in 1990 and, after being found guilty of later fraudulent activities, was imprisoned in 2004 and disqualified from being a company director for a period of ten years. According to Orzabal, "After the breakup [with Smith], things were a complete mess on the business end as well... So I was on my own, without a manager, without anybody that was familiar. And I needed to go through that. You can hear it on a song like 'Cold', where I say 'Look, I need distance, I need to be on my own, I don't want a relationship.'" The closing track of
Elemental, "
Goodnight Song", was released as the album's second single in the US (in lieu of "Cold"). It was also released as a single in some parts of Europe, although not in the UK. The "Cold" and "Goodnight Song" singles both featured the song "New Star" as a B-side; this song can be heard on
Gloryland World Cup USA 94, the official album of the
1994 FIFA World Cup. It can also be heard during the opening credits of the 1994 film
Threesome and appears on the film's soundtrack album, and was later included in the Tears for Fears compilation albums
Saturnine Martial & Lunatic (1996) and
Shout: The Very Best of Tears for Fears (2001). retrospectively expressed amusement at "Fish Out of Water", a diss track directed towards him. The title track of
Elemental was released in early 1994 as the album's third US single; the maxi CD version contains live tracks recorded from a Tears for Fears concert at
Wembley Stadium on 14 December 1993. Smith is also the subject of "Fish Out of Water", a song Orzabal referred to as his "
How Do You Sleep?" (
John Lennon's scathing 1971 song about his former
Beatles bandmate and songwriting partner,
Paul McCartney.) Of his relationship with Smith at the time, Orzabal stated, "I think it's similar to the animosity between a parent and a child; the parent wants the child to grow up and the child doesn't want to grow up. You know, for fuck’s sake, get out of the nest!" The opening lyrics of "Fish Out of Water" are a salvo against Smith (''"You always said you were the compassionate one/But now you're laughing at the sun/With all your high class friends you think you've got it made/The only thing you made was that tanned look on your face/With all your cigarettes and fancy cars/You ain't a clue who or what you are/You're dreaming your life away..."''). The song also makes references to "Neptune's Kitchen" (the studio in which
Elemental was recorded),
Arthur Janov's book
The Primal Scream (a major influence on Orzabal and Smith's lives and the first Tears for Fears album
The Hurting), and the 1983 Tears for Fears song "Memories Fade". Smith later responded to "Fish Out of Water" with the song "Sun King" in his album
Mayfield (1998). In 2022, Smith said, "I get a real kick out of 'Fish Out of Water', which is about me in a very derogatory way. I found it highly amusing." The song "Dog's a Best Friend's Dog" contains a reference to
Samuel Beckett's play
Waiting for Godot (''"Tell Mr. Godot I'm walking the dog"'') and the album's penultimate track, "Brian Wilson Said", is in part a
Beach Boys pastiche. The title is a backhanded reference to the
Van Morrison song "
Jackie Wilson Said (I'm in Heaven When You Smile)", which Morrison wrote about one of his idols,
Jackie Wilson. Similarly, Orzabal wanted to write a song about one of his idols,
Brian Wilson of the Beach Boys. ==Tour==