In 1808, John Smith of Fenton bought a large part of the estate, including the site of the Hall, from Eliot who moved back to London. Smith built a new Elmhurst Hall on his new estate. The new hall was built of brick with stone dressings in an
Elizabethan style. The front was gabled with seven bays and an off-centre porch. The hall was approached from a long drive from Tewnalls Lane. In 1816, Smith became
High Sheriff of Staffordshire. A small lodge was built on Tewnalls Lane in 1832. Smith lived at the hall until his death in 1840 when the hall was passed to his son, Charles. Charles Smith sold the hall in 1856 to Newton John Lane. Lane died in 1869. In 1874 his trustees sold the hall to George Fox (a retired Manchester businessman). During this time a lodge was built south of the hall, this lodge survives today and the building style matches that of the hall. In 1894 George Fox let the hall to the
Duke of Sutherland so that he could entertain the
Prince of Wales when he visited Lichfield for the centenary of the
Staffordshire Yeomanry, which had been founded by Eliot in 1798. In 1895, the hall was sold to
Henry Mitchell (the Smethwick Brewer). Mitchell lived in the house until his death in 1914. After Mitchell's death, the executors of his estate put it up for sale and, after years without sale, the hall was demolished in 1921. ==Today==