The near-simultaneous collapse of the Brythonic
Kingdom of Strathclyde and the disintegration of the Anglian
Earldom of Bamburgh in the 11th century removed ancient realms that had long kept the regions distinct, enabling the southward expansion of Gaelic
Alba and the spread of
Norman rule in northern England. This expansion was driven by
Norman,
Breton, and
Flemish forces encouraged by both Norman England and Alba, who dispossessed and colonised lands of Strathclyde, Galloway and
Lothian to
Northumbria, Cumberland (
Cumbria), and
Westmorland (Westmoringas). Previously, this broad region had been a complex mosaic of
Brythonic,
Anglian,
Gaelic—including
Norse and
Norse-Gael communities and polities. The border country, historically known as the
Scottish Marches, is the area on either side of the Anglo-Scottish border including parts of the modern
council areas of
Dumfries and Galloway and the
Scottish Borders, and parts of the
English counties of
Cumbria and
Northumberland. It is a hilly area, with the Scottish
Southern Uplands to the north, and the
Cheviot Hills forming the border between the two countries to the south. From the
Norman Conquest of England until the reign of James VI of Scotland, who in the course of his reign became
James I of England while retaining the more northerly realm, border clashes were common and the monarchs of both countries relied on
Scottish Earls of March and
Lord Warden of the
Marches to defend and control the frontier region.
Second War of Scottish Independence ) claimed by England in the
Treaty of Newcastle (1334). In 1333, during the
Second War of Scottish Independence, Scotland was defeated at the
Battle of Halidon Hill and
Edward III occupied much of the borderlands. Edward declared
Edward Balliol the new King of Scots, in exchange for much of southern Scotland and absolute supplication, but this was not recognised by the majority of the Scottish nobility who remained loyal to David II and conflict continued. By 1341, Perth and Edinburgh had been retaken by the Scots and Edward Balliol fled to England, effectively nullifying the supposed treaty. Edward would continue the war but would be unable to restore the puppet ruler Balliol to the throne and with the
Treaty of Berwick (1357) Scottish independence was once again acknowledged with any pretence to territorial annexations dropped.
Clans A 16th-century Act of the Scottish Parliament talks about the chiefs of the border clans, and a late 17th-century statement by the Lord Advocate uses the terms "clan" and "family" interchangeably. Although Lowland aristocrats may have increasingly liked to refer to themselves as "families", the idea that the term "clan" should be used for Highland families alone is a 19th-century convention. Historic Border clans include the following:
Armstrong, Beattie, Bannatyne, Bell, Briar,
Carruthers,
Douglas,
Elliot,
Graham, Hedley of Redesdale, Henderson,
Hall,
Home or Hume,
Irvine,
Jardine,
Johnstone,
Kerr,
Little,
Moffat,
Nesbitt,
Ogilvy,
Porteous, Robson, Routledge,
Scott, Thompson, Turnbull of
Bedrule,
Tweedie.
Scottish Marches During late medieval and early modern eras—from the late 13th century, with the creation by
Edward I of England of the first
Lord Warden of the Marches to the early 17th century and the creation of the Middle Shires, promulgated after the personal union of England and Scotland under
James VI of Scotland (James I of England)—the area around the border was known as the
Scottish Marches. For centuries the Marches on either side of the boundary was an area of mixed allegiances, where families or clans switched which country or side they supported as suited their family interests at that time, and lawlessness abounded. Before the personal union of the two kingdoms under James, the border clans would switch allegiance between the Scottish and English crowns depending on what was most favourable for the members of the clan. For a time a powerful local clan dominated a region on the border between England and Scotland. It was known as the
Debatable Lands and neither monarch's writ was heeded.
Middle Shires Following the 1603
Union of the Crowns,
King James VI & I decreed that the Borders should be renamed "the Middle Shires". In the same year the King placed
George Home, 1st Earl of Dunbar in charge of the pacification of the borders. Courts were set up in the towns of the Middle Shires and known reivers were arrested. The more troublesome and lower classes were executed without trial; known as "
Jeddart justice" (after the town of
Jedburgh in
Roxburghshire). Mass hanging soon became a common occurrence. In 1605 he established a joint commission of ten members, drawn equally from Scotland and England, to bring law and order to the region. This was aided by statutes in 1606 and 1609, first to repeal hostile laws on both sides of the border, and then to more easily prosecute cross-border raiders. Reivers could no longer escape justice by crossing from England to Scotland or vice versa. The rough-and-ready Border Laws were abolished and the folk of the middle shires found they had to obey the law of the land like all other subjects. In 1607 James felt he could boast that "the Middle Shires" had "become the navel or umbilic of both kingdoms, planted and peopled with civility and riches". After ten years King James had succeeded; the Middle Shires had been brought under central law and order. By the early 1620s the Borders were so peaceful that the Crown was able to scale down its operations. Despite these improvements, the Joint Commission continued its work, and as late as 25 September 1641 under
King Charles I,
Sir Richard Graham, a local laird and English MP, was petitioning the
Parliament of Scotland "for regulating the disorders in the borders". Conditions along the border generally deteriorated during the
Commonwealth and
Protectorate periods, with the development of
Moss-trooper raiders. Following the
Restoration, ongoing border lawlessness was dealt with by reviving former legislation, renewed continually in eleven subsequent acts, for periods ranging from five to eleven years, up until the late 1750s. ==Controversial territories==