The area where the community would develop was first recorded in an 1834 survey by Silvester Sibley. He listed the area as sandy, with rolling hills and trees including
oak,
hickory,
aspen, gum,
sassafras, whatleberry,
elm,
ash,
maple,
willow, and
birch. It also identified that it was in the "great marsh" of the
Kankakee. An 1835 survey by Jeremiah Smith likened the area to
Hades of Greek mythology. The survey of 1903 identified the lake as the largest in the state of Indiana. The town of English Lake began as a railroad station in 1860 for the
Chicago, Cincinnati and St. Louis Railroad, also known as the Panhandle Route. By 1864, the wildlife of the "Great Marsh" was bringing in hunters from around the country. The English Lake Gun Club was founded in 1864, adjacent to the railroad tracks. In 1897, the Brighton Rod and Gun Club of Brighton Park,
Chicago had established a clubhouse along the Panhandle Route. In 1900, the Railroad Club opened a clubhouse in English Lake for the Pennsylvania Railroad workers of
Logansport. A post office was established at English Lake in 1860, and remained in operation until it was discontinued in 1960. ==Geography==