". The first equivalent weights were published for
acids and
bases by
Carl Friedrich Wenzel in 1777. A larger set of tables was prepared, possibly independently, by
Jeremias Benjamin Richter, starting in 1792. However, neither Wenzel nor Richter had a single reference point for their tables, and so had to publish separate tables for each pair of acid and base.
John Dalton's first table of atomic weights (1808) suggested a reference point, at least for the
elements: taking the equivalent weight of
hydrogen to be one unit of mass. However,
Dalton's atomic theory was far from universally accepted in the early 19th century. One of the greatest problems was the reaction of hydrogen with
oxygen to produce
water. One gram of hydrogen reacts with eight grams of oxygen to produce nine grams of water, so the equivalent weight of oxygen was defined as eight grams. Since Dalton supposed (incorrectly) that a water molecule consisted of
one hydrogen and one oxygen atom, this would imply an atomic weight of oxygen equal to eight. However, expressing the reaction in terms of gas volumes following
Gay-Lussac's law of combining gas volumes,
two volumes of hydrogen react with one volume of oxygen to produce two volumes of water, suggesting (correctly) that the atomic weight of oxygen is sixteen. Many chemists found equivalent weights to be a useful tool even if they did not subscribe to the physics based
atomic theory. Equivalent weights were a useful generalisation of
Joseph Proust's law of definite proportions (1794) which enabled chemistry to become a quantitative science. French chemist
Jean-Baptiste Dumas (1800–84) became one of the more influential opponents of atomic theory, after having embraced it earlier in his career, but was a staunch supporter of equivalent weights. Equivalent weights were not without problems of their own. For a start, the scale based on hydrogen was not particularly practical, as most elements do not react directly with hydrogen to form simple compounds. However, one gram of hydrogen reacts with 8 grams of oxygen to give water or with 35.5 grams of
chlorine to give
hydrogen chloride: hence 8 grams of oxygen and 35.5 grams of chlorine can be taken to be
equivalent to one gram of hydrogen for the measurement of equivalent weights. This system can be extended further through different acids and bases. The final death blow for the use of equivalent weights for the elements was
Dmitri Mendeleev's presentation of his
periodic table in 1869, in which he related the chemical properties of the elements to the approximate order of their atomic weights. However, equivalent weights continued to be used for many compounds for another hundred years, particularly in
analytical chemistry. Equivalent weights of common reagents could be tabulated, simplifying analytical calculations in the days before the widespread availability of
electronic calculators: such tables were commonplace in textbooks of analytical chemistry. == Use in general chemistry ==