"I Don't Want It at All" AllMusic called the song an "
'80s-infused
dance-pop tune".
Galore magazine said it was a "bratty banger", while
Entertainment Weekly described it as a "shop-'till-you-drop-anthem".
Bakersfield.com labeled the track a "21st-century
pop update of
Madonna's '
Material Girl'".
Noisey writer Colin Joyce called the song a "glitzy
paean to consumerist excess".
Billboard ranked the single as the second best
Era 1 single, noting: "From the effortlessly cool,
synth-heavy intro to the song's bratty lyricism, Petras separated herself from her pop peers by dreaming up an expensive fantasy in this escapist jam."
"Heart to Break" Billboard ranked the single as the best Era 1 single, calling it "a master class" and pointing out that "if this is the quality of pop music she’s able to serve up so early in her career, we’re going to be paying attention to Petras for years to come". "1, 2, 3 Dayz Up" Chloe Gilke of
Uproxx was positive in their review of the song and cited as "one of Petras' best releases to date" further dubbing it as "a party anthem that clicks and pops with producer Sophie's
electro-pop magic." A writer for
DIYproclaimed the song as "an addictive pop banger made all the better by Sophie's slick production". Salvatore Maicki of
The Fader was also positive in their review, calling the song "straight up beach party music". Robin Murray of
Clash Music called the song "supremely addictive" and further added that track is "superbly feminine while linked utterly to digital developments, it manages to be both an outrageous pop statement and a real 'wtf?' moment." Justin Horowitz of
All Things Go praised the pairing for being "celebrated faces of women in the
trans community and have used their talents to spread awareness and equality regarding
LGBTQA+ rights." The music blog
Bit of Pop Music gave a mixed review, saying that the song might be a bit basic and repetitive in terms of vocals and lyrics" but stated that "the production is impeccable".
The Bozo gave the song a lukewarm review but compared it to the sounds of
Charli XCX and praised it as their favorite out of the three songs released together.
Billboard ranked the song as the fifth best
Era 1 single, noting that "the track has all the makings of a
pop hit straight out of
2010, but its
bubbly,
tropical touches update the sound for the modern era".
The Forty-Five Sophie Walker named it the 38th best
hyperpop song of all time. == Track listings ==