Coffel began her collegiate career for Kentucky in
2021. During her freshman year, she appeared in 59 games, and hit .337 with 60
hits, eight
doubles, one
triple, 16 home runs, and 56 RBI. Her 16 home runs set a freshman program record. Following the season, she was named to the SEC All-Freshman and All-SEC second teams. During her sophomore year in
2022, she appeared in 56 games and hit .423, with 69 hits, 11 doubles, one triple, 20 home runs, and 68 RBI. Her 68 RBI set a single-season program record. On May 20, 2022, during the first round of the
2022 NCAA Division I softball tournament against
Miami (OH), she recorded a single-game program record of seven RBI. Following the season, she was named to the All-SEC first team and a NFCA Second Team All-American, becoming the sixth All-American in program history. During her junior year in
2023, she appeared in 54 games and hit .440, with 55 hits, ten doubles, 19 home runs, and 55 RBI. She led the NCAA in walks (62), on-base percentage (.626), and OPS (1.595) and ranked second in slugging percentage (.968). Following the season, she was named to the All-SEC first team and a NFCA Second Team All-American for the second consecutive year. During her senior year in
2024, she appeared in 55 games and hit .319, with 46 hits, 12 doubles, 13 home runs, and 33 RBI. Following the season, she was named to the All-SEC first team for the third consecutive year and named to the All-SEC defensive team at shortstop. She was also named an NFCA Third Team All-American, becoming the first three-time All-American in program history. She finished her collegiate career with 230 hits, 189 runs scored, 212 RBI, 155 walks and 68 home runs in 224 career games. She is Kentucky's all-time leader in home runs, RBI and walks. ==Professional career==