Montreal Hockey Club and Montreal Wanderers intermediate team.Johnson's playing career began in 1902 in the Montreal City Hockey League where he would, at times, play with his junior, intermediate and senior teams all in the same weekend. He moved on to the
Canadian Amateur Hockey League in 1903 and played two seasons with the
Montreal Hockey Club, scoring 9 goals in 11 games in that time. He then moved on to join the
Montreal Wanderers of the newly formed
Eastern Canada Amateur Hockey Association in 1905, and finished tenth in league scoring with 12 goals. Ottawa came back to lead the second game 9–1, and tie the series, but two late goals by Montreal's
Lester Patrick gave Montreal the victory, 12–10 on aggregate, to win both the ECAHA championship, and the
Stanley Cup as Canada's national amateur champions. The ECAHA turned professional in 1906–07, and the Wanderers signed Johnson to a contract. Along with teammates
Jack Marshall,
Hod Stuart,
Frank Glass and
Riley Hern, Johnson became the first professional player ever allowed to compete for the Stanley Cup as the Wanderers defended a challenge by the New Glasgow Cubs of the Maritime Hockey League prior to the ECAHA season's start. including two in the final game of the second series against Kenora to help the Wanderers regain control of the Cup. on a 1911
Sweet Caporal postcard. Johnson was again named to the second all-star team on left wing in 1907–08. His offence fell in the ECAHA season, as he recorded nine goals in 10 games for the ECAHA champion Wanderers, but he added 11 goals in five Stanley Cup challenge games as the Wanderers successfully defended their title on three occasions. Johnson was an offensive star in the challenges, scoring four goals on one game against the Ottawa Victorias in a January 1908 challenge, and again scoring four in a game against the Winnipeg Maple Leafs in a March 1908 challenge. He scored one goal as Montreal again defended the Stanley Cup against the
Edmonton Eskimos in a challenge that preceded the 1908–08 ECAHA season, and added ten more during the campaign, but Montreal lost the league title to Ottawa, and with it control of the Stanley Cup. Johnson completed his second NHA season in
1910–11, scoring six goals and recording 60
penalty minutes in 16 games. Johnson and Glass played together on the 1902–03 Montreal St. Lawrence team in the Montreal City Hockey League before rejoining in the
1906 season on the Montreal Wanderers. At the onset of the 1905–06 season
Brooklyn Skating Club manager
Tom Howard tried to acquire both Johnson and Glass to his club, but the
AAHL rules committee ruled the Canadians ineligible to play with the American club on counts of professionalism.
New Westminster, Portland and Victoria When Lester and
Frank Patrick formed the
Pacific Coast Hockey Association (PCHA) in 1911, they sought to lure the NHA's top stars out west. Johnson, by then considered one of the game's best players, was among the players who jumped at the higher salaries the Patricks were offering. Johnson was placed on the
New Westminster Royals, and switched positions from left wing to cover-point (defence). Prior to the 1912–13 season, and despite being branded an "outlaw" by the NHA, Johnson appeared ready to return to the Wanderers as he signed a new contract with the eastern team. However, he previously signed a contract with the Royals, Johnson was again named to the all-star team that season, Following the season, he moved to
Portland, Oregon when the Royals transferred south to become the
Portland Rosebuds. He again made the all-star team in 1915, the first of five consecutive seasons in which he did so. He eventually signed with Portland, and was reported to have turned down lucrative offers to return to the NHA. The Rosebuds won the PCHA championship that season, and in doing so became the first American team to compete for the Stanley Cup. For Johnson, it marked his first in a Stanley Cup Final in six years, and was not without controversy. The Rosebuds faced the NHA's
Montreal Canadiens, and the entire series was played in Montreal. As a consequence of his jumping to the PCHA in 1911, Montreal Wanderers owner
Sam Lichtenhein had won a judgement against Johnson for $2,000 for breach of contract, but it was not enforceable unless he returned to the jurisdiction of Quebec's courts. When it became known that Lichtenhein would gain Johnson's salary for playing in the series, Johnson contemplated refusing to play. He decided to play in the series anyway, and scored one goal in the five-game series. Lester Patrick, managing the
Spokane Canaries, thought he had an agreement to secure Johnson's playing rights for the
1916–17 season. Portland had come to verbal agreement with Patrick that they would do so if he would relinquish claims on four players Portland sought to sign. When it was determined that some of those players would not report to Portland, the Rosebuds refused to relinquish Johnson, leading Patrick to claim he had been "double crossed". Remaining with the Rosebuds, Johnson posted a career-high 21 points in
1916–17. Johnson returned to hockey in 1926 with the
Los Angeles Palais-de-Glace when he played a couple of games in the
Commercial Hockey League before spending the winter of 1926–27 with the
Minneapolis Millers of the
American Hockey Association. He again returned to the game in 1928–29 with the
Portland Buckaroos of the
Pacific Coast Hockey League, then played two seasons in the
California Hockey League between 1929 and 1931 with the Hollywood Millionaires and then the San Francisco Tigers before retiring for good at the age of 45. ==Playing style==