Analysis Almost all historians have acknowledged the battle as a British victory, credited to the weak escort of light cruisers and destroyers which prevented the Italians from damaging the convoy, by repulsing an Italian squadron composed of a battleship and two heavy cruisers during massed Axis air attacks. Whilst acknowledging the British success, some authors write of the battle as a partial Italian success in delaying and turning the convoy aside. Nearly all sources agree that the Italian fleet inflicted significant damage and several casualties on the British squadron while suffering minimal damage and no casualties in return. In the following days, Axis aircraft caught the convoy at sea and chased the surviving steamers to the harbour; more than 80 per cent of the supplies were lost, making the British convoy operation a strategic failure.
Orders of battle ======== • 1st division Admiral Angelo Iachino •
battleship • •
destroyers • • • • • • (sunk by a storm after the action) • 2nd division, Admiral
Angelo Parona •
heavy cruisers • • •
light cruiser • • destroyers • • • • (sunk by a storm after the action) • Submarine •
Merchant Navy • Merchant ships • (sunk) • (sunk) •
Pampas (sunk) •
Talabot (sunk)
Royal Navy •
Carlisle squadron •
C-class light cruiser • •
5th Destroyer Flotilla (
Hunt-class destroyer escorts) from Tobruk • (sunk by a mine on 23 March) • • • • • • (lost en route to submarine 20 March) • 15th Cruiser Squadron (Admiral Vian) • light cruisers • • (slightly damaged) • (seriously damaged) •
14th Destroyer Flotilla • • • • (severely damaged) •
22nd Destroyer Flotilla • • (severely damaged) • • (seriously damaged) • (slightly damaged) • (structural damage due to high speed manoeuvring) •
Force K (Malta squadron) • light cruiser • • Destroyer • (
damaged by near miss during air attack on 23 March, sunk by air attack on 26 March while awaiting repair) • Submarines • • • • Alexandria • Submarine •
Battle damage According to British reports, " was struck on the after part of the bridge at 16:44" by a hit from the light cruiser ; 16 seamen were killed. According to Admiral Iachino, the hit was instead achieved by
Littorio's secondary guns, based on the range between the opposite warships at the time. Cruisers and were also damaged, with
Euryalus straddled by
Littorio at 16:43 and at 18:41.
Kingston was hit amidships by a shell from
Littorio that killed 15 men of her crew. and left the destroyer dead in the water, with her starboard
whaleboat torn apart, her anti-aircraft guns, searchlight tower and torpedo launchers shattered by the explosion. Some sources claim that she was hit by the guns of the heavy cruiser . Although
Kingston had an engine in flames and a flooded boiler, she managed to get back up to speed, reaching Malta the next day.
Havock was also badly damaged in a boiler by a near miss from
Littorio at 17:20; eight sailors died. Three more destroyers—, and —suffered lesser damage from cruiser fire. The Italian fleet expended 1,511 rounds of all calibres upon the British squadron; the only Italian destroyer to open fire was . The British cruisers had replied with 1,553 rounds and the destroyers with about 1,300 rounds as well as 38 torpedoes. Axis aircraft made continual attacks, mainly against the convoy, throughout the naval action and Royal Navy AA gunners claimed the destruction of seven Axis aircraft and damage to several more.
Subsequent operations Most of the escort force, short of fuel and ammunition and unable to find the convoy, turned back for Alexandria. The damaged destroyers and the cargo ships were sent on to Malta, with
Carlisle,
Penelope and
Legion. The next day, they were subjected to continuous air attacks. The cargo ship was sunk from harbour and the oil tanker was too damaged to reach
Valletta. The merchantmen,
Talabot and steamer
Pampas, reached Grand Harbour virtually unharmed.
Pampas had been hit by two bombs but these failed to explode.
Penelope attempted to tow
Breconshire, but the tow parted in heavy seas. She anchored short of the protective minefields and the destroyer
Southwold attempted to take her in tow, hitting a mine in the process. She was eventually towed into Marsaxlokk Bay by tugs. Axis air raids against Malta on 24 and 25 March failed to damage the three surviving convoy ships. On 26 March, German
dive bombers hit all three ships, sinking
Talabot and
Pampas that day with
Breconshire capsizing on 27 March. Much of
Breconshire′s oil was salvaged through the hole in her hull. Only about of cargo had been unloaded, of the that had been loaded in Alexandria. The Italian fleet units were no luckier after the battle. After failing to destroy the convoy, they were caught
en route to their bases by a severe storm that sank the destroyers and . While under repair in
dry dock at Malta,
Kingston was attacked a few days later by German aircraft and suffered further damage, this time beyond repair. She was scrapped
in situ in the following months. Whilst docked at Malta,
Havock, was a target for Axis aircraft and sustained further damage. On 3 April the ship was ordered to Gibraltar before her repairs were complete.
Havock ran aground off Kelibia, Tunisia, in the Strait of Sicily on 6 April and was wrecked, with one crewman killed in the incident. Another one died from wounds in the following days. On 8 April an Italian boarding party from the tug
Instancabile (former
Royal Yugoslav Navy Spasilac) searched the wreck looking for secret information.
Havock's crew and passengers were interned by the Vichy French at Laghouat in the Sahara but were released in November as a result of
Operation Torch. ==See also==