Eschalon: Book I has generally received favorable reviews from gaming critics, scoring 75% at
Metacritic from four reviews.
Macworld awarded the game 3.5/5, claiming that "
Eschalon: Book I is a great attempt at an 'old school' role-playing game that's worth playing, and definitely worth the download time." RPG Codex gave
Book I a positive review and praised the music in particular: "It's a perfect soundtrack for the depicted locations, sets the mood properly and, while the number of tracks is quite small, manages not to become boring." A common criticism from gamers that Riegsecker himself admits is the shortness of the game, with most players finishing
Book I in under twenty hours. In a September 2009 interview, Riegsecker revealed that sales were 25% higher than originally projected, and that about a year after the game's release they saw a profit. He also broke down the games sales by platform: 48% Windows, 42% Macintosh, and 10% Linux.
Linux Format reviewed the game and gave it a score of 7/10. == Awards ==