Modern scholarship generally agrees that Estrid contracted three marriages, a Rus' prince, a Norman duke, and Ulf Jarl, but their sequence is uncertain. Some accounts place the Rus' marriage first, followed by a short-lived Norman match and then her marriage to Ulf, while others treat the Norman connection as either preceding Ulf (c. 1017–1018) or following his death (c. 1027–1033). The evidence is late and contradictory, and the precise order of her early marriages cannot be established with certainty.
Russian prince According to a
scholion added in the 1080s to
Adam of Bremen's
Gesta Hammaburgensis ecclesiae pontificum, King Cnut "gave his sister Estrid in marriage to the son of the king of Russia." Indeed, it is known that Danish
Varangians were present in Kiev in 1018. Prince Il'ya died in 1020, and they had no known children. Earlier scholarship proposed a marriage in 1014–1015, and that Estrid's Rus' husband was one of the four sons of Grand Prince
Vladimir the Great who were killed in the civil wars following Vladimir’s death in 1015. This interpretation would make the Rus' marriage her first, preceding a short-lived or repudiated marriage to a Norman duke (see below). An alternative proposal, advanced by
P. A. Munch on the basis of a notice by
Florence of Worcester, equated Adam's "son of the king of Rus'" with
Bryachislav of Polotsk (a nephew of Yaroslav the Wise); this chain of identification has been largely rejected in modern scholarship.
Norman match In 1017, Estrid's brother Cnut became King of England, and in July, he wed
Queen Emma, the widow of
Æthelred and daughter of
Richard I, Duke of Normandy. Cnut further contracted a brief
marital alliance with the Norman ducal house for Estrid, but sources disagree whether Estrid’s marriage was to
Richard II or his son
Robert I, and whether it occurred before or after her marriage to Ulf.
Ralph Glaber, in his
Historiarum libri quinque, reported that an unnamed sister of Cnut married Robert, but
Adam of Bremen reported a marriage of Estrid (calling her Margaret) to Richard II. Adam further remarks that after the duke "went to Jerusalem”" she married Ulf, an element that fits Robert I (who undertook a Jerusalem pilgrimage in 1035) rather than Richard II, and is therefore commonly treated as a conflation of names and events in Adam's narrative. Norman sources, such as
William of Jumieges and
Orderic Vitalis, do not mention such a marriage for either duke, and historians disagree whether it was a short-lived marriage, a betrothal, or a result of confusion. An earlier
apocryphal story states that Robert I discarded Estrid in favour of his mistress
Herleva, sparking a conflict between Cnut and Normandy. According to this tale, she was supposedly ill-treated in various ways by Robert, who sent her back to England with "ignominy". On balance, modern works treat the episode with caution. Some Danish reference works identify the duke as Robert I, In all instances, Estrid returned to England, where she would marry for a third and final time.
Marriage to Ulf Jarl and widowhood Her brother Cnut then arranged a marriage for her with
Ulf Jarl. They became the parents of Sweyn II Estridsen, Asbjørn, and
Beorn Estrithson,
jarl of
Huntingdon in
England. She did not lose her brother's trust, and was granted large lands by him. The date of her death is unknown, but it can be no earlier than 1057 or later than 1073, as it is known that Bishop
William of Roskilde officiated at her funeral, and he was in office between 1057 and 1073. ==Aftermath==