College and amateur Kutler played
college soccer at
Colgate University between 2013 and 2016, in the
National Premier Soccer League with
Greater Binghamton FC, and in the
USL Premier Development League with
Michigan Bucks.
Professional Kutler was drafted in the second round (39th overall) of the
2017 MLS SuperDraft by
New York Red Bulls. Kutler made his first team debut on June 6, 2018, appearing as a starter in the team's 4–0 derby win over
New York City FC in the fourth round of the
2018 Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup. On June 13, 2018, Kutler made his first career MLS start, providing two assists in a 2–1 home win over
Seattle Sounders FC. On July 6, 2018, Kutler scored his first goal of the season for
New York Red Bulls II in a 6–1 victory over
Atlanta United 2. Kutler was released by the Red Bulls at the end of their 2018 season. On March 8, 2019, Kutler signed for
USL Championship club
Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC; he had been on trial for a week with Pittsburgh before signing a one-year contract.
Later career Kutler retired from professional soccer in 2019 and has played for amateur team
Sharktopus FC since 2022. ==Career statistics==