The planned deal has been denounced by scientists, trade unions, NGOs, European beef farmers,
environmental activists, and
indigenous rights campaigners. Protests against the deal have taken place. Governments and parliaments of the EU members states have also criticised the agreement. In October 2020, both the European Parliament and the European Commissioner for Trade
Valdis Dombrovskis have stated that the EU-Mercosur agreement "cannot be approved as its stands".
European farmers The deal is expected to trigger a huge surge of Argentine and Brazilian beef exports to all
EU countries. Under the agreement, the EU will open its markets to a
quota of up to 99,000 tonnes of beef per year at a preferential rate of 7.5% tariffs.
Food standards Recently, Brazilian beef imported into Europe was found to contain banned hormones and was confirmed to have entered the Irish food chain. Ireland fears the Mercosur deal will undermine confidence in EU's food standards. France has the same concerns, having strict food regulations within its own country. French farmers are protesting due to unfair competition from countries with looser regulation.
Environmentalists FIRMS satellite observation of deforestation in the
Mato Grosso state of Brazil. The transformation from forest to farm is evident by the paler square shaped areas under development. NGOs criticize the agreement being focused on sales of cheap meat and soy from South America into the EU on one hand and large sales of pesticides and cars from the EU to the Mercosur on the other. Scientists fear the environmental impact of those very goods, having a negative impact on global carbon dioxide output pushing climate change. French economists Charlotte Emlinger and Mathieu Parenti conclude that deforestation is a concern. Stanford economist Bard Harstad argues that if the tariffs were contingent on forest cover, the agreement could induce forest conservation instead of deforestation. Conventional meat production and soy cultivation in the Mercosur goes together with destruction of the
Amazon rainforest, which is one of the world's largest
carbon sinks. While inside some EU countries there is already meat overproduction. Use of pesticides increases global
loss of biodiversity and cause health risks for human beings. Intensified utilization of cars is criticized since fossil fueled cars amplify climate change. The expected effects oppose the
European Green Deal and the international
Paris Climate Agreement. The amount of carbon that the Amazon is absorbing from the atmosphere and storing each year has fallen by around a third in the last decade. This decline in the Amazon carbon sink amounts to one billion tonnes of carbon dioxide – equivalent to over twice the UK's annual emissions.
Recent historical framing After the election of
Jair Bolsonaro as
President of Brazil,
deforestation of the Amazon intensified. The increased rate of
rainforest destruction comes at a time of record beef exports from Brazil. As mentioned above, deforestation of the Amazon has intensified under Bolsonaro. He has been accused of weakening
Brazil's environmental ministry, The former environment minister,
Ricardo Salles, has imposed the lowest number of fines for illegal deforestation in a decade. Fears have been expressed in the
Financial Times that the "EU-Mercosur deal will cancel out climate efforts". Furthermore, civil society groups have protested that the predicted scale deforestation fostered by the deal would be non-compliant under the climate change goals under the
Paris Agreement. In June 2020, five NGOs filed a complaint with the
European Ombudsman, criticizing the external sustainability impact assessment for the trade pillar negotiations for not including current environmental data, especially concerning deforestation." On 17 April 2024, the
Greens/EFA Group in the
European Parliament published a study, "Alternatives for a fair and sustainable partnership between the EU and Mercosur: scenarios and guidelines" in which they outline four alternatives in which they feel they could support an association agreement between the EU and Mercosur. • Alternative 1, "Back at the table" proposes a renegotiation to more effectively integrate sustainability and legal obligations under international frameworks like the Paris Agreement and the
International Labour Organization (ILO) by adding a hierarchy clause to prioritize, where conflicts may arise, international environmental and labor standards over trade rules and also by enforcing specific commitments within the Trade and Sustainable Development (TSD) chapter with clearly defined sanctions for non-compliance. • Alternative 2, "Sustainability above all" proposes a shift away from traditional market access and trade liberalization towards a bilateral partnership that focuses exclusively on sustainability issues, notably using the
Sustainable Developments Goals (SDG) framework. • Alternative 3, "Focusing on what matters the most", proposes a relatively more targeted approach to cooperation, where the partnership would specifically focus on critical sustainability issues while still allowing for selective market access to the benefit of both parties. • Alternative 4, "Targeted Bilateral Strategic Partnerships" proposes an approach focused on critical raw materials by encouraging strategic partnerships that uphold responsible sourcing and sustainability in the trade and use of these materials, notably by developing joint ventures that emphasize the sustainable extraction of the materials necessary for technology like renewable energy as well as supporting the development of local industries in Mercosur countries.
Human rights activists Aside from the threat to the climate, deforestation would directly impact
Brazil's indigenous communities, He has also defunded agencies responsible for law enforcement in the Amazon. Indigenous communities are facing direct threats. In 2019 an estimated 20,000
goldminers illegally invaded
Yanomami Indigenous Territory, one of Brazil's largest indigenous territories. The letter noted the decision to put indigenous land demarcation under the remit of the
Agriculture ministry where the
agribusiness lobby has powerful sway and repeated attacks and invasions of indigenous land by profit seekers. In July 2019, a symbolic motion rejecting the trade deal was passed in
Dáil Éireann, the
lower house of the
Irish legislature, by 84 votes to 46. On 28 August Slovak Agriculture Minister
Gabriela Matečná said Slovakia would block the agreement because of Brazil's unacceptable approach to the Amazon fires. In September 2019, lawmakers on the
Austrian Parliament's EU subcommittee almost unanimously voted to reject the draft free trade agreement citing concerns over their national farming sector and the Amazon forest fires. As such the government is obliged to veto the pact at EU level, where all 28 member states and their parliaments must agree to trade deals. Lawmakers from the centre-right
ÖVP and the far-right
Freedom Party also voted to reject the deal. On 20 January 2020 the
government of the Belgian region of
Wallonia took formal position against the agreement. The
Walloon parliament unanimously (70–0) endorsed this position on 5 February 2020. The
Government of the Brussels-Capital Region stated on 14 July 2020 that the agreement was unacceptable in its current form and listed a series of preconditions. This position was endorsed by a
Parliamentary commission on 10 October 2020. On 2 June 2020 the
Dutch House of Representatives adopted a motion rejecting the agreement with a narrow majority. On 20 August 2020 the German Chancellor Angela Merkel expressed doubts about the EU-Mercosur trade deal and whether it could go through in its current form. On 29 September 2020
Tánaiste Leo Varadkar said that Ireland would not ratify the EU-Mercosur trade deal unless new enforceable environmental guarantees were added. On 2 December 2023 French president
Emmanuel Macron said during a
COP 28 press conference that he opposes the deal. Later that day, EU's Commission vice-president for trade
Valdis Dombrovskis cancelled a visit he would make along with a European delegation to a Mercosur summit in Rio de Janeiro on 7 December to reportedly announce the agreement had been concluded. Officials from Brazil also informed EU that Argentina's outgoing government said new commitments put in the final text (especially those regarding the environment) would require approval by the newly elected
government of Javier Milei, who was to be sworn in as president of Argentina on 10 December. Since the deal would include competences of both the EU and individual European countries, France (or any other EU state) could potentially veto the agreement, and additionally require all 27 national legislatures in the EU to approve it. ==Finalization, signature and ratification==