Local politics In 1881, he left the Republican Party and joined the Prohibition Party and in the same year ran for District Attorney in Waukesha county. From 1884 to 1920, he served as a delegate to the Prohibition national conventions, from 1888 to 1896 he served as a national committeeman from Wisconsin and again for Arizona and California from 1912 to 1920, at the 1884 convention he served as the Sergeant-at-Arms and gave one of the seconding speechings for
John St. John, and in 1900 he served on the platform committee. In 1877, he was elected as the Justice of the Peace in Waukesha and served until 1883 and then served as Police Justice until 1885. He later served on the school and public library board. Chafin ran for the House of Representatives in Wisconsin in 1882 and in Illinois in 1902. In 1886 and 1900, he ran for attorney general in Wisconsin and later ran for attorney general in Illinois in 1904. In 1898, he ran for Governor of Wisconsin. While running for president he was also simultaneously running for the Prohibition gubernatorial nomination in Illinois, but was defeated in the primary by Daniel R. Sheen. In August, he was swimming at the YMCA in Lincoln, Nebraska, where he almost drowned, but was rescued by three people. In the general election he received 254,087 votes for 1.71% of the total popular vote.
1912 Chafin started his second presidential campaign on January 5, 1912, in Tucson, Arizona, and then traveled east towards Atlantic City, New Jersey, where on July 12, 1912, he won the Prohibition presidential nomination on the first ballot with 594 delegates after having his name presented by F. J. Sibley and Watkins was selected as his vice president again after two ballots. After winning the nomination he traveled towards the western United States and campaigned in all of the states along the Pacific Coast before the general election. During the campaign he traveled a total of 36,300 miles through thirty states and received 208,156 votes for 1.38% of the popular vote in the general election.
1916 In December 1915, he stated that he would not seek the Prohibition presidential nomination again for the
1916 presidential election and that he believed that Representative
Richmond P. Hobson would receive the nomination. He also gave his support to
Henry Ford's
Peace Ship and that he would put forward a vote to add abolishing the
War and
Navy Departments and establishing a
Department of Peace at the 1916 National Prohibition Convention. Chafin attempted to draft Henry Ford for the Prohibition presidential nomination, but he made no attempt. At the national convention he put forward former New York Governor
William Sulzer for the presidential nomination, but he was defeated by former Indiana Governor
Frank Hanly with 440 delegates to 188 delegates on July 21, 1916. An attempt was made to make Hanly's nomination unanimous, but it failed after Chafin objected. He also objected and stopped efforts to rename the party to either the Progressive, American, or National party and criticized Virgil G. Hinshaw for writing to
John M. Parker in an attempt to fuse the Prohibition and
Progressive parties. In the general election, Hanly and
Ira Landrith received 221,302 votes for 1.19% of the popular vote. ==Later life==