It is estimated that every season since 1970 the fishery has taken 9-98% of the legal-sized male population with an average of 66% a year. The majority of this catch is caught in the first six weeks of the season. Despite this, the fishery has had a stable mean catch for over thirty years indicating populations are not overfished. This is likely due to the regulations put in place that allow crabs at least one year of sexual maturity before capture. Although 143 crabs are thrown back for every 100 kept, the trapping and subsequent throwing back of non-legal Dungeness does not seem to cause an overabundance of harm to the population. Soft-shelled crabs have been shown to have the highest mortality rates at just 9-25%. Due to catch averages staying consistent, it is assumed populations are healthy, but in reality very little is known about Dungeness crab populations. In California, Alaska, and Washington, research is minimal and information about populations is assumed from catch records. In Canada, two out of seven crabbing areas are examined twice every year. The other areas are studied inconsistently and usually in relation to specific research questions. In Oregon, monitoring programs are in place for mating success, genetic structure, population structure, and discard mortality. The effect of the fishery on other species is variable. The effects on benthic species and bycatch are relatively unknown, although the effects are assumed to be negligible for both. In Alaska and Canada there is no known effect on any other species. In Washington, Oregon, and California, humpback whales are known to be highly affected with a high of 19 humpbacks entangled in crabbing line in 2016. In California, leatherback turtles, orcas, and blue whales have also been known to be impacted. In recent years entanglements of all species have increased; this is attributed to increased reporting and changes in these species' migration due to changes in prey abundance as a result of climate change. Entanglements are lower than they could be due to the timing of the crabbing season: the first six weeks of the crabbing season (when most fishing occurs) happens before the migration of many species. The high seen in 2016 was likely due to a late opening of the season because of
toxic algal blooms.
Ghost fishing from lost equipment is a problem in the industry, the scale of which is generally unknown. It is estimated that 10-20% of gear is lost each year with 7.5-32.5% of that ghost fishing. Ghost fishing can entangle marine mammals, cause crab death, and harm the ecosystem. Additionally, lost gear may ghost fish in places far from their original spots due to currents and tides; buoys from lost pots in Oregon were recovered four years later in the Hawaiian islands. Overall,
Seafood Watch has given the Dungeness crab a
sustainable seafood rating of "Good Alternative" meaning they are okay to buy but be sure to be aware of potential concerns. ==Culinary use==