Eve's Plum toured independently throughout 1991 and 1992. The band signed a recording contract with
Sony Records in 1992. Their debut album,
Envy, was produced by Roger Greenawalt and released in 1993. The group's debut album failed to chart on the
Billboard 200. A "demonstration" version of the single in CD format was also released to radio stations that contained an additional song, "Twist It" that was not on the album - as well as the songs "Blue" and "Envy" from the album. The band's second single "Die Like Someone", also failed to make an impact. The album's third single, "I Want It All", became the only single of their career to chart. It spent one week on the
Modern Rock Chart at number 30 and two weeks in the
UK Top 100 peaking at #78. It was also featured in the film
The Next Karate Kid. In 1994, Eve's Plum released the
I Want It All Alive EP. The EP was a limited release. That same year Chris Giammalvo left the band and was replaced by Theo Mack on bass. In 1995, Eve's Plum recorded the single "Eye", for the soundtrack to the film
Higher Learning. The band also appeared in the film performing the song during the carnival scene. The group's second album,
Cherry Alive, was released in September 1995. The first single released from the album was called "Jesus Loves You (Not As Much As I Do)". The single failed to chart. Although three more singles were released from
Cherry Alive to radio: "Wishing the Day Away", "Cherry Alive", and "Fairy Princess", none of the singles were successful for the band and
550 Music dropped the group in 1996. Shortly before being dropped by their label the band, after wrapping a promotional tour for
Cherry Alive, returned to their home of NYC to write new songs for what would have been their third album. In the summer of 1996 they wrote a few new songs and performed a show in
Albany, New York. The show was recorded, and released as ''Eve's Plum Live in Albany''. However, it is extremely rare and it is unknown if any surviving copies still exist. There are a few songs which were performed live but didn't make it to a studio album, such as "Ride with You" (which was supposed to be on
Cherry Alive), "Lost in Space" (recorded for a compilation), "Ice Cream", "The Way You Look", "So What", and "Twist It" (released as a
B-side). ==Break up and post Eve's Plum==