Exai was received positively by critics. At
Metacritic, which aggregates scores from mainstream critics,
Exai has an
average score of 80 based on 26 reviews, indicating a score of "generally favorable". For
Exclaim!, Nick Storring stated that
Exai was not cutting edge, but still full of detail and intensity. Thomas Hannan of
The Line of Best Fit said the album could "really do with being broken up in to as many chunks as possible", but recommended people to listen to it, saying "there's always room in one's collection for records as smart as this". Andrew Ryce of
Resident Advisor compared the tracks on
Exai to
data overload, more prominent than on their previous projects. Concluding his review, Ryce felt the duo were more confident in their sound, but showed its real cohesion only in its "resistance to linearity and conventional melody". Tom Fenwick of
PopMatters stated how
Exai didn't mark a major shift in the duo's sound, but instead expanded on it and offered "unfathomable depths" for dedicated listeners. In a review for
The Quietus, Charlie Frame commented that
Exai drew ideas from entire Autechre's discography, while sound-wise remaining very similar to the projects such as
Oversteps and
Move of Ten. In the
Calgary Herald review, Francois Marchand gave the album 4/5 stars; while Marchand noted the relatively unapproachable nature of
Exai for new listeners, he highlighted it as one of the duo's most accessible albums. Both Grayson Haver Currin (
Pitchfork) and Andy Kellman (AllMusic) criticised
Exai's tracklist, noting some songs should be shortened or cut out entirely.
Mixmags Joe Muggs wrote that understanding the album wasn't easy, but nevertheless rewarding to the listener. Josh Becker of
Beats Per Minute gave a positive review, praising the album's ability to "impl[y] melody" rather than displaying it outright. Writing for
The Irish Times, Jim Carroll gave the album three stars, praising
Exai for being as intense as other releases from the duo and their openness to take risks. Mark Shukla of
The Skinny called
Exai a "thrilling renewal that leaves them perfectly poised for whatever leap they may choose to make next". For
BBC Music, Chris Power called the album "often abrasive and fidgety" and said it was easy to see it as the "first chapter of late-period Autechre" due to the duo revisiting past sounds with new focus. ==Track listing==