D'Amato founded Fake Fruit in
New York City in 2016, originally as a duo. At the time, she had applied to the
Berklee College of Music, but opted not to attend after an unpleasant experience with her audition, in which one of the panelists turned down the volume on her guitar amp while she was performing. By 2017, D'Amato had moved to
Vancouver,
British Columbia, and Fake Fruit had become a trio. She moved to the
Bay Area of California in 2018, where she met Alex Post and Miles MacDiarmid, who soon became the band's guitarist and drummer, respectively. The band cycled through what
Pitchfork later called a "rotating cast of bassists" over the next several years. Fake Fruit released their self-titled debut album in 2021 on
Sonny Smith's record label Rocks In Your Head Records. It was initially released on a limited vinyl pressing of only 250 copies, but this sold out quickly, as did subsequent pressings of 500 and 1,000 copies each. The band went on to tour with Grammy-winning band
Wet Leg and opened for such artists as
Alvvays and
Dry Cleaning. For their follow-up album, they worked with producer
Jack Shirley at his Atomic Garden Studio in Oakland. The resulting album,
Mucho Mistrust, was released on
Carpark Records in August 2024. ==Critical reception==