The
Toronto Star noted that "it's the cranky Frisell melodics and harmonics, always on the edge but never over it, that attract".
The Globe and Mail said that "Baker and Haden work wonderfully together at times ... but they can also bump along heavily, turning this esoteric set of originals and bebop classics ... into a rather hit-and-miss proposition." The
Hartford Courant stated that the album "has a sparse, clear sound that effectively mixes elegance with power."
The Ottawa Citizen opined that it "lacks the grace of its predecessor—substituting bombast for energy, and broad gestures for wry wit."
Stereo Review said that "the performances are trim and full of snap, thanks in no small part to the uncommon melodic lilt of Baker's rhythmic punctuations... He joins forces with Haden to lock in some irresistible grooves." The
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette deemed
Falling Off the Roof the seventh best jazz album of 1996; the album was also included on the
Albuquerque Journals list of the best jazz albums of the year.
The Encyclopedia of Popular Music noted, "Those who perceive Baker as the wild man of rock should investigate the excellent
Falling Off the Roof". ==Track listing==