Although the
Fame premiere did well in the
ratings, it was criticized for several choices. Unlike
Idol, where the producers had absolutely no connection to any performers before the auditions, Allen personally knew and had worked with a number of those who made it to the final rounds. In the middle of the season, the show announced they would bring in a "spoiler", a new finalist who could make it to the last round if the public enjoyed their work. They asked viewers to send in audition tapes by July 1. On July 2, they announced the winner -
Tyce Keith Diorio. Diorio was introduced on the show as a mere dance instructor, but his actual credits included being a former backup dancer for Fatone's
NSYNC,
Paula Abdul,
Janet Jackson,
Ricky Martin,
Jennifer Lopez, and dancing in an
Academy Awards piece choreographed by Debbie Allen, raising the suspicion of those who auditioned as the spoiler that the work they put into their audition tapes was completely in naught and the 'competition' for that slot was
fixed. The twist in the end did not affect the full contest, as the audience vote saw Diorio eliminated in the next episode.
Dropping ratings Unlike
American Idol, which focused on singing, or
Star Search, which divided talent up into several categories,
Fame sought a "triple threat", someone who could dance, sing, and have star quality. In the eyes of many viewers, most of the finalists had shockingly poor singing abilities, and so much emphasis was placed on dance numbers that their voices never improved. Viewer reaction quickly gave way to apathy and the ratings fell considerably. == Finalists ==