Feels So Good received mixed reviews from music critics.
AllMusic editor Andy Kellman found that the album was "nearly as solid as
Right Now, with more playful chemistry evident between the three members. Though the three biggest hits – "
It's OK!," "
The Last Goodbye," and a cover of
Blondie's cover of "
The Tide Is High" – are well-executed, easygoing pop songs, the group is at its best when it takes on the role of a modern disco act (as heard on "Feels So Good," "Love Won't Wait," and "Softer the Touch")."
BBC writer Alun Williams called
Feels So Good "one of the better CD's within the pop genre." He found that "there are a few gems amongst the numerous tracks," but also remarked that "the album's production is at best unadventurous and at worst repetitive and very unoriginal." Caroline Sullivan, writing for
The Guardian, felt that "the album is mush of a mushness, weighted in favour of system-built uptempo tunes such as the title track, written for them by an apparently listless
Kylie Minogue. At least these are marginally better than the ballads, sour little semi-acoustic snippets that sound like
Westlife on
oestrogen. What this album is crying out for is a kick in the tush from an avenging
Kelly Osbourne." British music website Peter Robinson from
NME called
Feels So Good "a dated collection of by-numbers pop, rarely any more imaginative than their cover of
Billie Piper's cover of Blondie's cover of "The Tide Is High." It gets worse: they even forced Kylie to soil her tiny hands, writing the title track."
Entertainment.ie wrote that
Feels So Goods "peculiarly watered-down brand of R'n'B is like the worst kind of fast food: uniform, tasteless, and forgotten the moment it's been consumed." Writing for
Yahoo! Music UK, Jamie Gill concluded that "though the majority of
Feels So Good is the kind of muzak you would hear in hell's own lifts, there are a couple of more interesting moments." ==Commercial performance==