Upon release,
Killuminati: The 7-Day Theory polarized critics and received mixed reviews, but it has retrospectively been met with widespread critical acclaim.
Muzik called the record one of the year's most important and noted that it "perfectly captures the dark tensions arising from the centre of the vicious heat that is the
City of Angels".
XXL awarded the album a perfect five-star rating. In a more critical review, writing for
the New York Times, Neil Strauss singled out "
Hail Mary" and "Krazy" as the album's standout tracks and praised its dark tone, but noted that both
Killuminati and
Snoop Dogg's
Tha Doggfather suffer from
Dr. Dre's departure from Death Row and that the album is inferior to
All Eyez on Me. "This one was clearly meant as filler, a way to burn off creative energy, put down his rivals at
Bad Boy Entertainment and tide fans over until the next album". While praising the production and Shakur's vocals,
Rolling Stone felt the album had nothing to offer lyrically. "The tracks are fat with funky menace and the choral-vocal effect in many of the raps has a street-corner, pass-the-bottle charge. Alas, the record – issued just two months after 2Pac's murder – merely perpetuates
Los Angeles hip-hop gangland stereotypes, in particular the
East Coast/West Coast feud that has gone beyond pointless all the way to deadly." Some reviewers commented negatively on the album.
AllMusic's
Stephen Thomas Erlewine gave the album 2.5 stars out of 5. "Everything about
Killuminati: The 7-Day Theory smacks of exploitation..." he observed. "Released only eight weeks after
Tupac Shakur died from gunshot wounds,
Death Row released this posthumous album under the name of Makaveli, a pseudonym derived from the Italian politician
Niccolo Machiavelli, who advocated using deception and fear on one's enemies. Naturally, the appearance of
Killuminati so shortly after Tupac's death led many conspiracy theorists to surmise the rapper was still alive, but it was all part of a calculated marketing strategy by Death Row – the label needed something to sustain interest in the album, since the music here is so shoddy." He also condemned the record for concentrating on "nothing but tired G-funk beats and back-biting East Coast-West Coast rivalries".
Legacy with rappers The emotion, anger, and eerie nature showcased on the album has been admired by a large part of the hip-hop community,including other rappers. "There are a lot of 2Pac records I like," said
50 Cent, "but this is consistent all the way through. You could put this on and clean your whole house." Rapper
J. Cole named it his favorite album of all time, he commented on the album saying, "Collectively, from 'Hail Mary' to 'Krazy' to 'Against All Odds,' it's deep. This album gets better for me as time goes on.
Me Against the World is like that too, but
Makaveli is really the one where the older I get, the more of it I get. Every year that I get older, I hear this album differently. I know more about life, so I'm like, 'Oh shit, this is what he meant.' So
Makaveli is super special." ==Track listing==