Two of Fen's brothers played a single VFL match with
Essendon, on the same day (Saturday, 9 September 1905):
Edwin Patrick "Ted" McDonald (1875–1919), and
Archibald William Campbell "Arch" McDonald (1883–1942). Strongly built (at enlistment he stood 5 ft 7½ in, weighed 11 st 9 lbs, and had an expanded chest measurement of 37 in), McDonald was fast on his feet, and had some success as a handicap runner. Once in Melbourne, he played in the Metropolitan Amateur Football Association competition with the Carlton District team. Carlton noticed his impressive performance, signed him up, and he played his VFL debut, aged 20, against
St Kilda, on 29 July
1911 (round fifteen). Carlton thrashed St Kilda by 114 points, and none of the forwards saw much of the ball as most of those up the ground were concentrating on feeding the ball to Carlton's full-forward,
Vin Gardiner, who kicked 10 goals. Situated in the
back pocket, McDonald saw little of the play – St Kilda only scored 2.3 (15) – yet he did make it down to the forward line and kicked one goal. During
the next season McDonald played nine senior games, mainly in the backline; and at the end of the season, he transferred to Melbourne. In
1913, he played one senior match for Melbourne, against Essendon on 14 June 1913 (round nine). Essendon beat Melbourne by 41 points. One match report noted that "McDonald was another player who did a lot of hard work for Melbourne under discouraging circumstances", whilst another commented that "McDonald… did very good work". McDonald then returned to the District team, and did not play another VFL match. He played for the Carlton District team in 1914 as well, and concentrated on completing the last year of his studies. ==Soldier==