Fever Breaks was released to a generally positive critical reception.
Review aggregator website
Metacritic assigned the album an average score of 75, indicating "generally favorable reviews".
Rolling Stone, which rated the album three and a half stars out of five, said that, while the album "blazes no new emotional or musical ground," it "feels like a vital career summation, a survey course sampler in a word-swilling artist's narrative gifts and endearing empathy."
NPR, similarly, praised the way in which Ritter "tweaks and further reinvigorates a sound and songwriting approach that's lost none of its vitality or urgency in 20 years." Comparisons were drawn to
Bob Dylan and
Leonard Cohen on tracks "The Torch Committee", "Old Black Magic", and "Ground Don't Want Me", while "Losing Battles" bore comparisons to
Crazy Horse. Many reviews praised Isbell's production.
The Line of Best Fit said that Isbell and his band give "Ritter's material a whole lot of muscle and bite in places," while
The Irish Times, giving the album three stars out of five, noted that Isbell contributed to "a tougher framework around this latest batch of Ritter's songs." James Christopher Monger of
Allmusic said that the 400 Unit provided "soaring harmonies and some truly emotive violin work," which added "considerable sonic heft to the proceedings." ==Track listing==