Wingtip coupling experiments Wingtip coupling experiments were evolved from the concept of adding extra floating panels to extend the effective wingspan of an aircraft, in the hope this would extend the range of the aircraft. This would theoretically act in the same manner as the long narrow wings of a glider. It is reported that the Germans experimented with the idea in 1944 and 1945 by coupling two equal-sized light planes together, then the idea was further developed by
Richard Vogt, who came to the US from Germany after World War II. The idea was tested at Wright Field in the late 1940s using a
Douglas C-47A Skytrain and
Culver Q-14B Cadet. These tests showed the idea had promise, and
Republic Aviation was awarded a contract to investigate further. Thus began the Tip Tow project.
Project MX-1016 (Tip Tow) The MX-1016 program (code named "Tip Tow") sought to extend the range of jets to give fighter protection to piston-engined bombers with the provision for in-flight attachment/detachment of the fighter to the bomber via wingtip connections. The Tip Tow aircraft consisted of a specially modified
ETB-29A (serial number
44-62093) and two
EF-84D (serial numbers
48-641 and
48-661). A number of flights were undertaken, with several successful cycles of attachment and detachment, using at first a single aircraft, then two. The pilots of the F-84s maintained manual control when attached, with roll axis maintained by elevator movement rather than
aileron movement. Engines on the F-84s were shut down to save fuel during the "tow" by the
mother ship, and in-flight engine restarts were successfully accomplished. Wing flexibility of the B-29 as well as wing-tip vortices caused concern, and the mechanisms for attachment required modifications. The first hookup of both F-84s with the B-29 occurred on the 10th flight on 15 September 1950. The longest flight with all connected was on 20 October 1950, and lasted for 2h 40min. All of these flights were accomplished with manual control of the F-84 aircraft. Republic received an additional contract to continue the experiments by incorporating an automatic flight control system. Meanwhile, as the modifications proceeded, additional test flights were made, including night flights. The automatic flight control modifications were ready for testing in March 1953, and a number of hookups were made with only one or the other of the F-84s while attempting to sort continuing electrical issues. On 24 April 1953, over
Peconic Bay, New York State, the left-hand F-84 hooked up and the automatic system was activated. The F-84 immediately flipped over onto the wing of the B-29 and both crashed with loss of all five crew and the F-84 pilot. The pilot of the right-hand F-84D, Major
Clarence E. "Bud" Anderson wrote of the Tip-Tow experiments in an article entitled
Aircraft Wingtip Coupling Experiments published by the
Society of Experimental Test Pilots.
Project Tom-Tom In parallel, a similar configuration, called Tom-Tom, was being developed using JRB-36F 49-2707, which was previously used in the early FICON trials and two RF-84F (serial numbers
51-1848 and
51-1849). The aircraft were attached wingtip-to-wingtip using articulated arms and clamps. Although several successful hookups were performed by Convair pilots Doc Witchell, Beryl Erickson, and Raymond Fitzgerald in 1956, turbulence and vortices continued to present a major problem. On 23 September 1956, RF-84F
51-1849, piloted by Beryl Erickson, was actually torn away from the right
wing tip of the JRB-36F. All aircraft landed safely but the concept was deemed too dangerous. Developments in the area of
inflight refueling at the time promised a much safer way of extending the range of the fighters and Project Tom-Tom was canceled. ==FICON concept==