In a retrospective review,
Stephen Thomas Erlewine from
AllMusic called "Fields of Gold" a "peaceful
ballad", and said that it ranks as a classic.
Larry Flick from
Billboard magazine described it as a "deeply alluring ballad with atmosphere to burn." He added, "Impeccably produced, it features a strong seductive vocal (and nice harmonica strains) from
Sting, as well as lovely harplike acoustic guitar figures from band mate
Dominic Miller. Among the most distinctive and beguiling songs the man has written, it's sure to earn a powerful multiformat reception, and thereby steal a few million hearts." Irish
Bray People viewed it as "moody but ultimately likeable". David Bowling from the
Daily Vault named it one of the "brilliant pop songs of the 1990s." He stated that it remains "the perfect ballad. It is a wistful love song looking back on love gained." Alan Jones from
Music Week gave "Fields of Gold" a score of four out of five and named it Pick of the Week, calling it a "lilting, haunting, soothing, almost
folky song". He added that "the uncluttered arrangement and intimate vocals are excellent". In a 2015 review, Pop Rescue commented, "This song is so wonderfully mellow, and flows so perfectly, that it’s near impossible to find fault with it."
Andrew Collins from
Select felt the album was at its best with songs like "Fields of Gold", saying it was "massaging the menopause". In an interview at the Liverpool Institute for Performing Arts,
Paul McCartney stated that "Fields of Gold" was a song he wished he'd written himself. ==Music video==