Record Mirror critic Stuart Bailie praised "the variety of emotional shades" in
Roland Gift's singing on
Fine Young Cannibals, adding that the group "are one of the few bands to realise the value of a sparse presentation" and "have an emotional charge that's sorely needed just now".
Spins Annie Russo wrote, "The lyrical content on most cuts isn't terribly complicated, one thought turned around a few times; but the sparseness lays snug next to the inlays and wrap-arounds of Gift's voice, along with the more than competent instrumental work, forever keeping the vocals buoyed up." Stewart Mason, in an
AllMusic retrospective review, commented that
Fine Young Cannibals "is a powerful and satisfying debut" with "uniformly strong" songs.
Nigel Williamson called the album "an artful
soul-pop concoction loaded with hooks and hits" in
Uncut, while in
Classic Pop,
John Earls said that it was a testament to the group's reputation as "the soul band even the indie kids love". ==Track listing==