Earliest mentions of the club in the local press appear in 1894 with its early success against the
Berrigan Football Club. The club held an Annual General Meeting in 1895 and entered the Murray Border Football Association, then in 1899 joined the
Federal District Football Association . Finley FC competed in the
Southern Riverina Football Association from 1905 to 1931 and played in 16 grand finals in that period and winning 10 premierships. Walter Barthelson, a 17 year old Finley footballer from "The Rocks", Tocumwal, New South Wales was injured whilst playing football in 1908 against Leniston and died after an abdominal operation the following day. In 1915, Finley footballer, Sidney Jones was killed shortly after the outbreak of World War I. Some players from Finley have risen to the major football league in the country, the
Australian Football League (AFL), including – •
Shane Crawford •
Tom Hawkins. •
Allan Jeans (1955–59, 77 games for St Kilda and premiership coach of St Kilda 1966, premiership coach for Hawthorn 1983, 1986 & 1989), •
Jack Hawkins (1973–81, 182 games- Geelong), •
Darren Jackson and •
Bert Taylor (1934–36, 39 games- Melbourne) Dan O'Bryan also played for the club in 2025. ==Football competitions timeline==