The congregation's roots date back over seventy years before its official founding.
John Brainerd led the first
Presbyterian worship services in the town from 1767 to 1776, followed by the Rev. John Plotts, who hosted the services in the upper floor of his academy. The first building, dedicated December 17, 1845, was replaced by the current structure in 1887. The site is above an underground river, which has been the source of some difficulties. Expansions to provide classroom space, a gymnasium, and offices took place in 1925 and 1957. On November 1, 2013, after 154 years as part of the Monmouth Presbytery of the
Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) and its predecessor denominations, First Presbyterian was received into
ECO: A Covenant Order of Evangelical Presbyterians. The decision to move to the newly created, more
Evangelical, denomination was taken after two years of prayer, study, and discernment. ==Theology==