The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction entry written by
David Langford and
Neal Tringham calls
Flamesong "an exotic travelogue" that is less successful than
The Man of Gold, but interesting nonetheless. Langford and Tringham opine that
Flamesong is better than the three Tékumel novels that followed it, and that Barker was more talented as a
world-builder than he was as a novelist. A retrospective review posted on the genre fiction blog
Pornokitsch describes the novel as more consistent and better balanced than
The Man of Gold. Regardless, the plot consists mainly of "railroaded events" driven by "a magical place-hopping, plot-forwarding tube." Despite its obvious shortcomings, the novel is "action-packed" and "a lot of fun", successfully inviting the reader to learn more about Tékumel. A website dedicated to Tékumel collecting describes the novel as the best written of the series. While the "dynamics among the soldiers" are sometimes implausible, the characterization is generally good and the novel has a better structured plot than its predecessor.
Flamesong may also function as a "gold mine of information" for Tékumel fans. Writing for the
Black Gate website, John O'Neill describes the novel as "an even more ambitious sequel [that] was highly acclaimed… but only by those few who read it." ==Reviews==