Jennifer Hillman from the
School Librarian wrote that "throughout the book, the vivid and dramatic events surrounding these characters and the prejudices their families face, is delicately and sensitively handled". She says it is not only "a story of intolerance, but it is also an inspiring tale of friendship and courage which children will undoubtedly adore". Nicolette Jones wrote in
The Sunday Times that "not every phrase is finely turned, but the storytelling is, as always, irresistible and the characters clasp your heart. Don't forget, this is Michael Morpurgo: you will need a handkerchief for the happy ending". In her review for ''
The Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books'', Natalie Berglind said "this quiet, introspective story is pulled along by the magnetic voices of Vincent and Kezia, who easily draw readers into the past". She also notes how Morpurgo "touches upon the common debate about the intentions of individual Nazis through the nuanced portrayal of a German officer who displays frequent kindness and the family's measured reaction – they may not all be wicked, but they do wicked things". She sums up her review by stating, "Lorenzo is sensitively portrayed, and he has great depth of character in spite of his limited speech, and overall, readers will learn much about history, culture, friendship, and morality with an unambiguously happy ending that is worth a read".
Kids Book Review opined that the novel is "filled with compassion and love, and this perfectly crafted story is full of humanity and hope. It's about family and what defines it, friendship and fate, and how people who are outcasts – people with uncommon minds, are the ones that make a difference to the common person's life". ==See also==