The rivalry between the three schools has traditionally been non-conference; it was only in 2004 that Miami moved to the
Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC), joining Florida State, which played its first season as a member of the ACC in 1992. Prior to this move, Miami was in the
Big East Conference, which it joined in 1991. Before joining their respective conferences, both teams had been
independent. Florida has been in their conference, the
Southeastern Conference (SEC), for much longer, having been one of its charter members in 1932. Although Florida State has played both Miami and Florida annually for roughly 50 years, Florida has not played Miami in an annual series since 1987. The Florida Cup has been awarded to the winner of the round-robin between the three Florida schools since 2002. Thus, the cup can only be awarded during years in which all three teams play against one another. Florida State defeated both Miami and Florida in 2010, 2011, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2022, and 2023, but was denied six additional Florida Cups because Florida and Miami did not play each other those years. The cup has been given only eight times. Miami won the first three Florida Cups awarded, having played Florida in the
2002 and
2003 regular seasons, and the
2004 Peach Bowl. Florida won its first Florida Cup in
2008, and Florida State won the
2013 Florida Cup with wins over Florida and Miami in the regular season. Florida took the next edition in
2019, having beaten Miami in the
Camping World Kickoff and defeating Florida State in the regular season finale. Miami was awarded the trophy in the
2024 and
2025 seasons, after beating both the Seminoles and the Gators in consecutive years. ==Future Cup years==