As the quotations that follow show, Follett was generally compared favourably with
Fowler, doing for Americans, as it were, what Fowler had done for the writer of
British English. He was considered by expert reviewers to have struck the right balance of prescriptivity and to have trodden the right line between outdated, schoolmarmish rules and laissez-faire liberality in matters of grammar and usage. The novelist, poet, literary critic and journalist
Malcolm Cowley reckoned that the
Guide was "Sensible, vigorous, and cogent ... Follett deserves a place on the shelf beside Fowler." Poet and critic
Mark Van Doren wrote "This is a book that any conscientious writer will continue to consult as long as he lives."
Clifton Fadiman wrote: "A work comparable to Fowler's classic
Modern English Usage." Eliot Fremont-Smith wrote in
The New York Times: "Few have been more outspoken [in their attack on the permissive view] than the late Wilson Follett; and his
Modern American Usage ... may be taken as the most detailed and sustained attack so far on the notion that anything goes – or should go." The critic and author
Louis Kronenberger wrote that Follett's book was "the most highminded book of its kind since Fowler, and perhaps the only book with comparable credentials, sensibilities, and standards." ==See also==