Follow This encountered a major legal conflict in early 2024, when ExxonMobil filed a lawsuit in
Texas federal court against Follow This and Arjuna Capital, aiming to block a shareholder resolution on greenhouse gas emissions. Amid a backlash against
ESG proposals,
Exxon pursued this
litigation after the groups withdrew their proposal, arguing the matter could recur and seeking to restrict future filings through court orders. The move sparked widespread investor outrage. Leading
institutional shareholders, including
CalPERS and
Norges Bank Investment Management denounced Exxon for undermining shareholder rights.
CalPERS announced plans to vote against Exxon's entire board in protest, calling the lawsuit “reckless” and “designed to punish two small groups that dared to speak truth to power”.
Norges Bank publicly opposed the re-election of Exxon director Joseph Hooley, citing concern over the company's “unusual and aggressive tactics”. Dozens of asset owners issued statements defending
shareholder democracy and urging reliance on
SEC processes as the proper mechanism for resolving
proxy disputes. In June 2024, the court dismissed the case against Follow This on
jurisdictional grounds, and the case against
Arjuna Capital was dropped after the firm committed not to refile the proposal. Follow This welcomed the ruling, warning the lawsuit could have set a dangerous precedent for future climate-focused shareholder activism. In 2025, Follow This did not file a climate resolution for the first time since 2016. The decision was attributed to legal and political pressure in the United States, including state-level actions against
ESG policies by American investors. Despite not filing a resolution, Follow This rallied 24% of
BP shareholders to vote against the re-election of BP's chairman after a reversal in the oil company's climate strategy. == References ==