Forever, Michael was generally well-received by music critics.
Tom Hull described it as "transitional as you'd expect from the 16-year-old artist" and gave the album a B+ rating, while
Robert Christgau from
The Village Voice gave it an A−. Christgau found that at 16, Michael's voice combines autonomy and helpless innocence in effective proportions. He also gets production help from Brian Holland (who begins one side like Barry White and the other like the Ohio Players) and a few romantic ballads (sure hit: "One Day in Your Life") that are as credible on their own terms as the rockers. In a retrospective review,
AllMusic editor William Ruhlmann called
Forever, Michael a "more mature effort for the 16-year-old singer but lacked the contemporary dance style that had given Jackson and his brothers a career rebirth with 'Dancing Machine' the year before". While "Jackson sang appealingly, the arrangements were noticeably similar to many older Motown charts, and there was little here to hint that, four years hence, on his next solo album,
Off the Wall, Jackson would emerge as a major star." Leah Greenblatt from
Entertainment Weekly remarked that the album's "comparatively adult soul sound confirms he was ready to move on from his days as Gordy's bubblegum boy wonder. Still, the fairly standard midtempo grooves do little to foreshadow the sonic revelations that were soon to come." ==Track listing==