In 1991, following the critical and commercial failure of her biography of
Estée Lauder, author
Lee Israel struggles with financial troubles,
writer's block, and alcoholism. Her only friend is her cat, which has a health issue. Lee hopes to write a biography of comedian
Fanny Brice, who died in 1951. Her literary agent Marjorie sharply rejects the idea, noting that Brice’s life no longer interests people. Marjorie explains that Lee, with her difficult personality, is responsible for her own career slump. With Marjorie unable to secure her an
advance for a new book, regardless of subject matter, Lee resorts to selling her possessions to cover living expenses. She sells a personal letter she received long ago from
Katharine Hepburn to a used bookstore merchant and autograph dealer named Anna. Lee begins spending time with old acquaintance Jack Hock after a chance encounter with him at a gay bar called Julius’. He reveals to her that he has been banned from all locations of the
Duane Reade chain of stores because he was caught shoplifting. Lee visits a Manhattan library's special collections department to research Fanny Brice and discovers two letters typewritten by Brice. She removes one of them from the building, takes it to Anna's store, and shows it to her. Anna makes Lee an offer that is lower than what she was expecting, due to the letter's bland content. Lee returns home and uses a typewriter to add a postscript to the letter. Lee returns to the store where Anna, amused by what "Fanny Brice" wrote "several decades ago", offers Lee $350. Anna reveals to Lee that she has written some short stories and is soliciting advice about whether they are good enough to be published. The
socially phobic Lee replies cautiously, as this is apparently the first time in many years that a woman has tried to befriend her and is asking for her help with getting something published. Lee uses some of the $350 Anna gave her to pay for veterinary treatment of her sick cat. The veterinary clinic previously had turned her and her cat away because of insufficient funds. Lee, emboldened by her success with selling the Brice letter, starts forging and selling letters supposedly written by deceased celebrities, incorporating intimate details to command high prices. Anna, a fan of Lee's biographies, tries to initiate a romantic relationship but may have another motive. On their dinner date, she gives Lee a manila envelope containing an original short story with the hope that Lee will critique it. Moments after they leave the restaurant, the
socially phobic Lee appears to rebuff Anna. In some of Lee's letters, she has
Noël Coward make references to his social life that reflects his homosexuality. A used-book dealer named Paul buys one of them from Lee and sends it to a friend of his who knew Coward. The recipient doubts Coward would have risked his privacy and relays his suspicions. Paul then raises an alarm that leads to Lee's customers
blacklisting her. Unable to sell more forgeries, she has Jack sell them on her behalf, since the customers do not know he has a connection to Lee. She also starts stealing authentic letters from libraries and archives for Jack to sell, replacing them with forged duplicates. While Lee is out of town committing one such theft, she lets Jack stay in her apartment. He brings a young waiter from the gay bar Julius’ to join him there. Lee’s cat dies while under Jack’s care during the night he and the waiter spend together. Lee ends their friendship but continues their partnership out of necessity. The
FBI arrests Jack while he is attempting a sale. He cooperates with them, resulting in Lee being served with a court summons. She retains a lawyer, who advises her to show contrition by getting a job, doing community service, and joining
Alcoholics Anonymous. In court Lee says she enjoyed creating the forgeries but that her actions were ultimately not worth it because she lost her cat and her friendship with her criminal accomplice. He “may have been an idiot, but he tolerated me, and he was nice to have around.” The judge sentences Lee to five years'
probation and six months'
house arrest. During house arrest Lee skips her court-ordered AA meeting to meet with Jack, who is dying of
AIDS, at the gay bar Julius’. They reconcile. Lee does not comment on or ask about his health. He grants her permission to write a memoir about their escapades. Sometime later, while Lee is passing a bookstore, she sees a
Dorothy Parker letter she forged that is now on sale for $1,900. She writes the store owner a sarcastic note from the deceased Parker revealing that the letter is a fake. After reading the note, the owner goes to retrieve the letter but then decides to keep it on display. == Cast ==