In May 2011, RTÉ's
Prime Time aired "
Mission to Prey", a documentary produced by journalist
Aoife Kavanagh, which alleged that Reynolds, during his missionary work in Kenya, had raped a minor named Veneranda, impregnating her and fathering a child named Sheila. The programme claimed Reynolds had secretly provided financial support to Sheila for years, with Veneranda and Sheila appearing on air to support the allegations. Reynolds, then serving as parish priest in Ahascragh, County Galway, had offered to undergo
DNA testing to prove his innocence before the broadcast, but RTÉ reportedly declined. The revelation of the false accusations sparked controversy. RTÉ issued a public apology to Reynolds on 19 November 2011 and
Prime Time Investigates was suspended. Prominent RTÉ figures, including
Mike Murphy,
John Bowman, and Sean O’Rourke, publicly condemned the libel. The Irish Missionary Union criticised RTÉ for retaining Kavanagh on its
Morning Ireland programme, citing "double standards". In November 2011, Reynolds reached an undisclosed out-of-court libel settlement with RTÉ. His solicitor also requested that the jstice minister,
Alan Shatter, who had initially endorsed the documentary, publicly clarify Reynolds' innocence, which Shatter did. The Irish government ordered an inquiry by the
Broadcasting Authority of Ireland, which found that RTÉ had breached broadcasting standards, leading to reforms in editorial oversight. == Reinstatement and legacy ==