Born and raised in Watertown, Wisconsin, Utley attended the
University of Wisconsin, from which he graduated with honors in 1929. He did his graduate literary studies at Harvard, earning the M.A. in 1934 and the Ph.D. in 1936. At Harvard, he came under the influence of
George Lyman Kittredge in English who encouraged Utley's study of folklore. In 1936, he married Ruth Alice Scott and they had three children: Philip Lee, Andrew Scott, and Jean Marie. Utley began his teaching career in 1935 in the English department at
Ohio State University; in 1973, he received the title of Professor of English and Folklore. He also served as visiting professor of folklore at the
University of California at Berkeley and
UCLA. He was president of the
American Folklore Society from 1951 to 1952, president of the
American Name Society in 1956, and president of the College English Association in 1969. Among his honors were being named Fellow of the American Folklore Society, Fellow of the American Anthropological Association, and Executive Council member of the
Modern Language Association. == Scholarship ==