Cirofici was arrested in connection with the Rosenthal murder on July 25, 1912. Cirofici was convicted of the Rosenthal killing after 25 minutes of
jury deliberation on November 19, 1912. He was
sentenced to death on November 26, 1912, for the Rosenthal killing along with
Charles Becker,
Harry Horowitz, and "Lefty Louis Rosenberg" by Judge
John W. Goff. The four gunmen appealed their conviction, but Cirofici's guilty verdict, along with the verdicts of Horowitz and Rosenberg, were affirmed on February 25, 1914, with Becker winning a new trial. In March 1914, Cirofici's sister, Mary Cirofici, collected signatures for an appeal for
clemency to New York State Governor
Martin H. Glynn. Glynn denied the appeal on April 7, 1914. On April 10, 1914, Cirofici's lawyers submitted five
affidavits from five alibi witnesses. Two days later, on April 12, 1914, Cirofici's mother and sister attempted to see Glynn to beg for clemency. Glynn refused to allow them into his office and stated it would not be fair as he had not seen the mothers of any of the other men convicted. Cirofici reportedly confessed his guilt in the killing 2 hours before he was executed in the
electric chair in
Sing Sing Prison on April 13, 1914, despite warden
James M. Clancy's attempt to grant him a temporary reprieve to allow Glynn to evaluate Cirofici's confession. ==References==