In 1950, Sedita was elected as a City Court
judge. He resigned from his job on the City Court bench on September 6, 1957 to pursue his mayoral bid. On November 5, 1957, he was elected mayor, defeating incumbent
Steven Pankow. During this term,
urban renewal was continued and the Ellicott District Project was completed. He lost his bid for re-election to mayor in the November 7, 1961 election, when
Chester A. Kowal was elected mayor. In 1962, President
John F. Kennedy nominated Sedita to the post of Federal Customs
Collector of the Port of Buffalo; he held that post until May 7, 1965. He was elected as mayor to a second term on November 2, 1965. At the 1966 Democratic State Convention, held in
Buffalo Memorial Auditorium, he was nominated to run for
New York State Attorney General. He was defeated in the
general election by
Louis J. Lefkowitz. In June 1967, during the
Buffalo riot at the Michigan Avenue YMCA, the mayor faced an angry crowd of young African Americans during an East Side street confrontation. He was re-elected on November 4, 1969. He ran for
Erie County executive in 1971, but was defeated by
Edward Regan in the general election. Because of health concerns, on February 8, 1973 Sedita submitted a letter of resignation to the Buffalo Common Council, to become effective on March 5, 1973. == Personal life ==