From 1985 to 2023, Caprio served as a Providence Municipal Court Judge. Caprio released his book
Compassion in the Court on February 4, 2025.
Caught in Providence Parts of the proceedings over which he presided, featuring low-level citations, ran for more than two decades on local television. Caprio's TV series,
Caught in Providence, originated on
PEG access television in Rhode Island in 1988 and was later picked up by
ABC station
WLNE-TV in 2000, initially airing late on Saturday nights. After a hiatus,
Caught in Providence returned in 2015 and aired after the 11 o'clock newscasts on Saturdays until September 2017. Clips from this show went viral in the 2010s, starting with one about Caprio's reaction to a parking ticket issued 2 seconds before permissibility. The program also received coverage from media organizations around the world, such as
NBC News. On September 24, 2018,
Caught in Providence went into national syndication. The show was renewed for a second season of syndication in January 2019.
Caught in Providence was produced by Caprio's brother Joe Caprio, who has stated that the show would cease filming with Caprio's retirement. Fifty episodes are consolidated into a single season and made available on
Prime Video. In 2017, his videos in the courtroom went
viral, with more than 15 million views. In 2022, views of
Caught in Providence neared 500 million, and one video shared on Pulptastic had 43.6 million views on
YouTube. He became well known for his empathy and light humor in court. The
Caught in Providence YouTube channel has 2.92 million subscribers. Caprio also made appearances in the series
Parking Wars, adjudicating several cases of traffic violations. ==Community outreach==