As 1990 began Graves was making plans to run for a third consecutive term as mayor of Paterson, as the same law changes that lengthened a mayor's term of office also removed the limits on how many consecutive terms a mayor could serve. It would not come to pass, however. On the morning of March 4, 1990, at his home in Paterson's
Lakeview section, Graves was stricken with a massive heart attack. He was rushed to nearby
St. Joseph's Hospital, but doctors could not revive him and he was pronounced dead shortly thereafter. He was buried in Holy Sepulchre Cemetery in Totowa, New Jersey. Graves' Senate seat was filled by State Assemblyman
John Girgenti, who was appointed to the seat and confirmed in April 1990. The vacant mayoral seat was contested between Girgenti's Assembly colleague
Bill Pascrell, City Council President Rev. Albert Rowe, Freeholder Michael Adamo, and Councilman At-Large Roy Griffin. Pascrell, who served as a
United States representative from New Jersey's 9th Congressional District until his own death in 2024, won the seat and served as mayor until he resigned from both of his elected positions to take his seat in Congress. ==Popular culture==